Probability Assessment of the Seismic Risk of Highway Bridges with Various Structural Systems (Case Study: Tehran City)

Abstract

Considering the development of urban transportation systems and the importance of highway bridges in a city’s resilience against earthquakes, it is critical to pay special attention to the seismic risk evaluation of highway bridges. The most significant issue to consider is the assessment of possible direct and indirect damages imposed on bridges before an earthquake. After this, the best practices for bridge rehabilitation can be adopted to minimize the induced damage. In this paper, we assessed the seismic risks associated with all 713 highway bridges in Tehran province (the capital of Iran). These bridges were initially divided into six categories according to their structural system and construction year and were also classified by whether or not seismic design was included. Among the 84,000 earthquakes recommended by the researchers’ ten-thousand-year catalog, a set of 50 ground motion records was selected in the course of a probabilistic approach via the Optimization-based Probabilistic Scenarios (OPS) algorithm in an attempt to obtain the least amount of error compared to the original catalog in the final hazard curve in different regions of Tehran province. Afterward, the seismic fragility curves were plotted in four damage states of slight, moderate, extensive, and complete for the six bridge structural systems of simple, steel, concrete slab box, concrete slab–steel box, concrete slab, and steel girder–concrete slab. The results of the fragility curves extracted from the decision tree analysis were validated with those developed from incremental dynamic analysis (IDA) for a bridge case study modeled in the OpenSEES software V2.5.0. Later, using logical relationships, seismic risk curves were drawn for each structural system. The results show that, in general, the average seismic damage of bridges over ten years old is 0.88 times the average damage of bridges less than ten years old. The highest level of vulnerability is associated with the simple bridge system with a median vulnerability of 0.44. Moreover, the lowest level of vulnerability is related to the steel girder–concrete slab bridge system with a median vulnerability of 0.98, showing an increase of approximately 2.2 times in the median vulnerability. In addition, based on the sensitivity analysis results, the indirect and total risk levels increase almost exponentially with increasing the reconstruction index.