Morphological Crown Attributes Contributing to Differential Height and Diameter Growth among Families in a Coastal Douglas-Fir Progeny Test: Crown Structural Evidence for Crop Ideotypes

Abstract

Theoretical tree crop ideotypes have long and narrow live crowns with a high total leaf area. This crown form allows more efficient exploitation of site resources, in part by physically occupying less growing space per unit leaf area and by packing a greater number of trees into a given area. Genetic selection for crop ideotypes has been proposed as a strategy for maximizing productivity per unit area in stands managed under intensive silviculture. The primary objective of this study was to test the relationship between the relative growth performance of different families in a Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii var. menziesii [Mirb.] Franco) progeny test and morphological crown attributes that conform to a theoretical crop ideotype. The overarching goal was to identify attributes conferring superior height and diameter growth on families and to facilitate the incorporation of these attributes and associated growth mechanisms into hybrid growth models for intensively managed plantations. Crown structural attributes were measured on destructively sampled trees and averaged for the entire crown and each third of live crown length among families. Multivariate analysis revealed that crown attributes averaged over the entire crown performed best for identifying families with different height and diameter growth, followed successively by the bottom, middle, and top crown third. Trees with relatively short branch lengths and steep branch angles tended to have higher total leaf area per unit crown length (TLACL), and this structural attribute showed a strong positive correlation with cumulative diameter growth. The ratio of crown width to crown length (CWL) was moderately and negatively correlated with cumulative height growth. The families displaying the most rapid diameter growth in this progeny test conformed to a theoretical crop ideotype, while those with the most rapid height growth displayed crown attributes with a less obvious relationship to the crop ideotype concept. TLACL implied one possible mechanism driving genetic gain in Douglas-fir families, given its high heritability and strongly positive correlation with growth performance. Incorporating TLACL as an explanatory variable in diameter growth models could at least partly represent different genetic levels. TLACL is less strongly correlated with height growth rate, so incorporating CWL may better represent genetic effects on height growth models.