Tutorial for Stopped-Flow Water Flux Measurements: Why a Report about “Ultrafast Water Permeation through Nanochannels with a Densely Fluorous Interior Surface” Is Flawed

Abstract

Millions of years of evolution have produced proteinaceous water channels (aquaporins) that combine perfect selectivity with a transport rate at the edge of the diffusion limit. However, Itoh et al. recently claimed in Science that artificial channels are 100 times faster and almost as selective. The published deflation kinetics of vesicles containing channels or channel elements indicate otherwise, since they do not demonstrate the facilitation of water transport. In an illustrated tutorial on the experimental basis of stopped-flow measurements, we point out flaws in data processing. In contrast to the assumption voiced in Science, individual vesicles cannot simultaneously shrink with two different kinetics. Moreover, vesicle deflation within the dead time of the instrument cannot be detected. Since flawed reports of ultrafast water channels in Science are not a one-hit-wonder as evidenced by a 2018 commentary by Horner and Pohl in Science, we further discuss the achievable limits of single-channel water permeability. After analyzing (i) diffusion limits for permeation through narrow channels and (ii) hydrodynamics in the surrounding reservoirs, we conclude that it is unlikely to fundamentally exceed the evolutionarily optimized water-channeling performance of the fastest aquaporins while maintaining near-perfect selectivity.