Exploration of Potential Broad-Spectrum Antiviral Targets in the Enterovirus Replication Element: Identification of Six Distinct 5′ Cloverleaves

Abstract

Enterovirus genomic replication initiates at a predicted RNA cloverleaf (5′CL) at the 5′ end of the RNA genome. The 5′CL contains one stem (SA) and three stem-loops (SLB, SLC, SLD). Here, we present an analysis of 5′CL conservation and divergence for 209 human health-related serotypes from the enterovirus genus, including enterovirus and rhinovirus species. Phylogenetic analysis indicates six distinct 5′CL serotypes that only partially correlate with the species definition. Additional findings include that 5′CL sequence conservation is higher between the EV species than between the RV species, the 5′CL of EVA and EVB are nearly identical, and RVC has the lowest 5′CL conservation. Regions of high conservation throughout all species include SA and the loop and nearby bases of SLB, which is consistent with known protein interactions at these sites. In addition to the known protein binding site for the Poly-C binding protein in the loop of SLB, other conserved consecutive cytosines in the stems of SLB and SLC provide additional potential interaction sites that have not yet been explored. Other sites of conservation, including the predicted bulge of SLD and other conserved stem, loop, and junction regions, are more difficult to explain and suggest additional interactions or structural requirements that are not yet fully understood. This more intricate understanding of sequence and structure conservation and variability in the 5′CL may assist in the development of broad-spectrum antivirals against a wide range of enteroviruses, while better defining the range of virus isotypes expected to be affected by a particular antiviral.