Accidental Encounter of Repair Intermediates in Alkylated DNA May Lead to Double-Strand Breaks in Resting Cells

Abstract

In clinics, chemotherapy is often combined with surgery and radiation to increase the chances of curing cancers. In the case of glioblastoma (GBM), patients are treated with a combination of radiotherapy and TMZ over several weeks. Despite its common use, the mechanism of action of the alkylating agent TMZ has not been well understood when it comes to its cytotoxic effects in tumor cells that are mostly non-dividing. The cellular response to alkylating DNA damage is operated by an intricate protein network involving multiple DNA repair pathways and numerous checkpoint proteins that are dependent on the type of DNA lesion, the cell type, and the cellular proliferation state. Among the various alkylating damages, researchers have placed a special on O6-methylguanine (O6-mG). Indeed, this lesion is efficiently removed via direct reversal by O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT). As the level of MGMT expression was found to be directly correlated with TMZ efficiency, O6-mG was identified as the critical lesion for TMZ mode of action. Initially, the mode of action of TMZ was proposed as follows: when left on the genome, O6-mG lesions form O6-mG: T mispairs during replication as T is preferentially mis-inserted across O6-mG. These O6-mG: T mispairs are recognized and tentatively repaired by a post-replicative mismatched DNA correction system (i.e., the MMR system). There are two models (futile cycle and direct signaling models) to account for the cytotoxic effects of the O6-mG lesions, both depending upon the functional MMR system in replicating cells. Alternatively, to explain the cytotoxic effects of alkylating agents in non-replicating cells, we have proposed a “repair accident model” whose molecular mechanism is dependent upon crosstalk between the MMR and the base excision repair (BER) systems. The accidental encounter between these two repair systems will cause the formation of cytotoxic DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs). In this review, we summarize these non-exclusive models to explain the cytotoxic effects of alkylating agents and discuss potential strategies to improve the clinical use of alkylating agents.