On the Indispensability of Isogeometric Analysis in Topology Optimization for Smooth or Binary Designs

Abstract

Recently, isogeometric analysis (IGA), which unifies the computer-aided design (CAD) model and the computer-aided engineering (CAE) model, has been adopted to develop the isogeometric topology optimization (ITO) framework. However, a critical study on the indispensability of IGA in topology optimization to take the place of the conventional finite element method (FEM) is still lacking. In the current work, two important problems are extensively discussed: (1) The lower numerical precision of the FEM resulting from the disunification between the CAD and CAE models damages the effectiveness of the topology optimization, which suggests the indispensability of IGA in the replacement of the FEM in optimization; (2) a material penalization model is required to ensure the generation of a full loading-transmission path during optimization in classic density-based methods, which causes a greater overestimation of structural stiffness and also suggests the necessity of an ersatz material model. The current paper describes a promising ITO method with point-wise design to gain smooth or binary symmetrical topologies, for which an extended density distribution function (DDF) was constructed to describe the structural topology. Two benchmarks of the stiffness-maximization problem and compliant mechanism are studied in the context of the above issues. Finally, several topologically optimized designs with symmetry are obtained using the ITO method.