Comparing Six Vegetation Indexes between Aquatic Ecosystems Using a Multispectral Camera and a Parrot Disco-Pro Ag Drone, the ArcGIS, and the Family Error Rate: A Case Study of the Peruvian Jalca

Abstract

A Parrot Sequoia four-band multispectral camera mounted on a Parrot Disco-Pro Ag drone allowed us to study six vegetation indexes in four lakes within the Tilacancha Private Conservation Area (PCA) in 2021. These lakes are a source of water for consumption for more than 32,000 people in the province of Chachapoyas in the Amazon region of Peru. To obtain the six vegetation indexes (Green Normalized Difference Vegetation Index—GNDVI; Leaf Chlorophyll Index—LCI; Modified Chlorophyll Absorption in Reflective Index—MCARI; Normalized Difference Red Edge—NDRE; Normalized Difference Vegetation Index—NDVI; and Structure Intensive Pigment Index 2S—SIPI2), Pix4DFields 1.8.1 software was used. The sensitivity and distribution of pixel values were compared in histograms and Q–Q plots for each index. Statistical differences were established for each index, and the SIPI2 obtained the highest level of sensitivity concerning the degree of pixel distribution in the ranges shown in the histogram according to the standard deviation; however, the values of all the indexes were not disregarded, because they showed statistical differences between lakes despite their closeness. The family error rate and Tukey-Kramer HSD statistics allowed for establishing statistical differences between pairs of lakes. The six vegetation indexes can be used to detect and analyze the dynamics of biological beings with photosynthetic activity in aquatic ecosystems of the Peruvian Jalca.