Evaluation of CMIP6 HighResMIP Models and ERA5 Reanalysis in Simulating Summer Precipitation over the Tibetan Plateau

Abstract

The High Resolution Model Intercomparison Project (HighResMIP) experiment within the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project Phase 6 (CMIP6) has enabled the evaluation of the performance of climate models over complex terrain for the first time. The study aims to evaluate summer (June to August) precipitation characteristics over the Tibetan Plateau (TP). Precipitation derived from HighResMIP models and ERA5 are compared against the China Merged Precipitation Analysis (CMPA). The nineteen models that participated in HighResMIP are classified into three categories based on their horizontal resolution: high resolution (HR), middle resolution (MR), and low resolution (LR). The multimodel ensemble means (MMEs) of the three categories of models are evaluated. The spatial distribution and elevation dependency of the hourly precipitation characteristics, which include the diurnal peak hour, diurnal variation amplitude, and frequency–intensity structure, are our main focus. The MME-HR and ERA5 both show comparable ability in simulating precipitation in the TP. The MME-HR has a smaller deviation in the precipitation amount and diurnal variation at various altitudes. The ERA5 can better simulate the elevation dependence of the frequency–intensity structure, but its elevation dependence of diurnal variation shows a trend opposite to the observations. Although the MME-HR produces the best simulation results among the three MMEs, the simulation effects of HighResMIP’s precipitation in the TP do not necessarily improve with increasing the horizontal resolution from LR to MR. The finer model resolution has a small impact on the simulation effect of precipitation intensity, but the coarser model resolution will limit the generation of heavy precipitation. These findings give intensive measures for evaluating precipitation in complex terrain and can help us in comprehending rainfall biases in global climate model simulation.