Comparison of Canopy Clumping Index Measuring Methods and Analysis of Their Impact

Abstract

The clumping index (CI) is a commonly used vegetation dispersion parameter used to characterize the spatial distribution of the clumping or random distribution of leaves in canopy environments, as well as to determine the radiation transfer of the canopy, the photosynthesis of the foliage, and hydrological processes. However, the method of CI estimation using the measurement instrument produces uncertain values in various forest types. Therefore, it is necessary to clarify the differences in CI estimation methods using field measurements with various segment lengths in different forest types. In this study, three 100 m × 100 m plots were set, and the CI and leaf area index (LAI) values were measured. The CI estimation results were compared. The results show that the accuracy of CI estimation was affected by different forest types, different stand densities, and various segment lengths. The segment length had a significant effect on CI estimation with various methods. The CI estimation accuracy of the LX and CLX methods increased alongside a decrease in the segment length. The CI evidently offered spatial heterogeneity among the different plots. Compared with the true CI, there were significant differences in the CI estimation values with the use of various methods. Moreover, the spatial distribution of the CI estimation values using the ΩCMN method could more effectively describe the spatial heterogeneity of the CI. These results can provide a reference for CI estimation in field measurements with various segment lengths in different forest types.