Comparative Analysis of Machine Learning-Based Predictive Models for Fine Dead Fuel Moisture of Subtropical Forest in China

Abstract

The moisture content of fine dead surface fuel in forests is a crucial metric for assessing its combustibility and plays a pivotal role in the early warning, occurrence, and spread of forest fires. Accurate prediction of the moisture content of fine dead fuel on the forest surface is a critical challenge in forest fire management. Previous research on fine surface fuel moisture content has been mainly focused on coniferous forests in cold temperate zones, but there has been less attention given to understanding the fuel moisture dynamics in subtropical forests, which limits the development of regional forest fire warning models. Here, we consider the coupled influence of multiple meteorological, terrain, forest stand, and other characteristic factors on the fine dead fuel moisture content within the subtropical evergreen broadleaved forest region of southern China. The ability of five machine learning algorithms to predict the moisture content of fine dead fuel on the forest surface is assessed, and the key factors affecting the model accuracy are identified. Results show that when a single meteorological factor is used as a forecasting model, its forecasting accuracy is less than that of the combined model with multiple characteristic factors. However, the prediction accuracy of the model is improved after the addition of forest stand factors and terrain factors. The model prediction ability is the best for the combination of all feature factors including meteorology, forest stand, and terrain. The overall prediction accuracy of the model is ordered as follows: random forest > extreme gradient boosting > support vector machine > stepwise linear regression > k-nearest neighbor. Canopy density in forest stand factors, slope position and altitude in terrain factors, and average relative air humidity and light intensity in the previous 15 days are the key meteorological factors affecting the prediction accuracy of fuel moisture content. Our results provide scientific guidance and support for understanding the variability of forest surface fuel moisture content and improved regional forest fire warnings.