Comparative Grain Size Analysis of Modern Flood Sediments Based on Graphic and Moment Methods in the Lower Yellow River (Huang He), China

Abstract

Grain size analysis of flood sediments is a key method for understanding the sedimentary environments of rivers worldwide; however, there is limited knowledge of how to effectively reflect the sedimentary environment of lower Yellow River (Huang He) flood events using grain size parameters. In this study, two widely used grain size analysis methods, the graphic method (GM) and moment method (MM), were compared, and their applicability to flood sediment analysis in the lower Yellow River was evaluated. Modern flood sediments (n = 143) in the lower Yellow River featured a fine-grained texture and were classified as silty sand (4.95 ≤ Φ ≤ 5.03) characterized by an inadequate sorting ability. The grain size distribution patterns obtained using the GM and MM revealed positive and extremely positive deviations with sharp and flat peaks, respectively. A strong correlation (0.6966 ≤ R2 ≤ 0.9961) was observed between the mean grain size and the sorting coefficient obtained using the GM and MM. Thus, both methods were deemed suitable and could be used interchangeably. Our results indicate that the MM should be applied to assess skewness because it provided comprehensive information regarding flood sediments in the lower Yellow River, whereas the GM is recommended for kurtosis analysis, as it highlighted the primary sedimentary dynamics during flood events. Methods must be selected based on the sedimentary environment when analyzing grain size parameters.