Estrogen-Receptor Loss and ESR1 Mutation in Estrogen-Receptor-Positive Metastatic Breast Cancer and the Effect on Overall Survival

Abstract

In patients with metastatic estrogen-receptor (ER)-positive HER2-negative breast cancer, the loss of ER expression and the mutation of ESR1—the gene encoding the ER receptor—are mechanisms for resistance to endocrine therapy. We aimed to determine the frequency of these mechanisms and their interaction. Metastases were retrieved from our pathology files. ESR1 hotspot mutations resulting in p.(D538G), p.(Y537S), and p.(L536H) were determined by means of pyrosequencing. Clinical data were retrieved from electronic medical records. A total of 136 metastases were available for analysis. ER loss was found in 23 metastases (17%). ESR1 mutations were found in 18 metastases (13%), including p.(D538G) in 9, p.(Y537S) in 7, and p.(L536H) in 2. ESR1 mutation and ER loss were mutually exclusive (p = 0.042), and ESR1 mutation was associated with endocrine therapy (p = 0.002). ESR1 mutation was found in two primary breast cancers. ESR1 mutations are rare in primary breast cancer and develop in metastases during endocrine therapy. Furthermore, ER loss had a statistically significant negative effect on overall survival when compared to patients without ER loss, with a rate ratio of 3.21 (confidence interval 1.95–5.26). No such effect was observed for ESR1 mutations, with a rate ratio of 1.15 (confidence interval 0.67–1.95). We conclude that ER loss and ESR1 mutation together account for 30% of the resistance to endocrine therapy.