Evaluation of Different Algorithms for Estimating the Growing Stock Volume of Pinus massoniana Plantations Using Spectral and Spatial Information from a SPOT6 Image

Abstract

Precise growing stock volume (GSV) estimation is essential for monitoring forest carbon dynamics, determining forest productivity, assessing ecosystem forest services, and evaluating forest quality. We evaluated four machine learning methods: classification and regression trees (CART), support vector machines (SVM), artificial neural networks (ANN), and random forests (RF), for their reliability in the estimation of the GSV of Pinus massoniana plantations in China’s northern subtropical regions, using remote sensing data. For all four methods, models were generated using data derived from a SPOT6 image, namely the spectral vegetation indices (SVIs), texture parameters, or both. In addition, the effects of varying the size of the moving window on estimation precision were investigated. RF almost always yielded the greatest precision independently of the choice of input. ANN had the best performance when SVIs were used alone to estimate GSV. When using texture indices alone with window sizes of 3 × 5 × 5 or 9 × 9, RF achieved the best results. For CART, SVM, and RF, R2 decreased as the moving window size increased: the highest R2 values were achieved with 3 × 3 or 5 × 5 windows. When using textural parameters together with SVIs as the model input, RF achieved the highest precision, followed by SVM and CART. Models using both SVI and textural parameters as inputs had better estimating precision than those using spectral data alone but did not appreciably outperform those using textural parameters alone.