TLC and HPTLC‐APCI‐MS for the rapid discrimination of plant resins frequently used for lacquers and varnishes by artists and conservators

Abstract

AbstractIntroductionDepending on their terpenoid and phenolic constituents plant resins can be classified as diterpenoid, triterpenoid or phenolic resins; thereby the profile of diterpenes and triterpenes is considered as genus‐ or even species‐specific.ObjectivesWe aimed to develop a simple, rapid, inexpensive, sensitive and specific method for the identification of resin‐specific triterpenoid and phenolic compounds in plant resins using (HP)TLC [(high‐performance) thin‐layer chromatography] combined with APCI‐MS (atmospheric pressure chemical ionisation mass spectrometry) and post‐chromatographic detection reactions.MethodsTwenty resin samples from different plant species were analysed. Different extraction procedures, post‐chromatographic detection reagents as well as various sorbents and solvents for planar chromatography were tested. To evaluate the potential of the optimised (HP)TLC‐APCI‐MS methods, parameter such as limit of detection (LOD) was determined for selected marker compounds.ResultsOur protocol enabled qualitative analyses of chemotaxonomic molecular markers in natural resins such as dammar, mastic, olibanum and benzoin. For the first time, the application of thionyl chloride‐stannic chloride reagent for a specific post‐chromatographic detection of triterpenes is reported, sometimes even allowing discrimination between isomers based on their characteristic colour sequences. For triterpene acids, triterpene alcohols and phenolic compounds, detection limits of 2–20 ng/TLC zone and a system precision with a relative standard deviation (RSD) in the range of 3.9%–7.0% were achieved by (HP)TLC‐APCI‐MS. The applicability of the method for the analysis of resin‐based varnishes was successfully tested on a mastic‐based varnish. Thus, the method we propose is a helpful tool for the discrimination of resins and resin‐based varnishes with respect to their botanical origin.