Effects of essential caregiver policies on COVID‐19 and non‐COVID‐19 deaths in nursing homes

Abstract

AbstractFederal authorities banned nursing home visitation in the early days of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID‐19) pandemic. However, there was growing concern that physical isolation may have unintended harms on nursing home residents. Thus, nursing homes and policymakers faced a tradeoff between minimizing COVID‐19 outbreaks and limiting the unintended harms. Between June 2020 and January 2021, 17 states implemented Essential Caregiver policies (ECPs) allowing nursing home visitation by designated family members or friends under controlled circumstances. Using the Nursing Home COVID‐19 Public File and other relevant data, we analyze the effects of ECPs on deaths among nursing home residents. We exploit variation in the existence of ECPs across states and over time, finding that these policies effectively reduce both non‐COVID‐19 and COVID‐19 deaths, resulting in a decrease in total deaths. These effects are larger for states that implemented policies mandatorily or without restrictions, indicating a dose‐response relationship. These policies reduce non‐COVID‐19 deaths in facilities with higher quality or staffing levels, while reducing COVID‐19 deaths in facilities with lower quality or staffing levels. Our findings support the use and expansion of ECPs to balance resident safety and the need for social interaction and informal care during future pandemics.