Changing trends in the decision-making preferences of women with early breast cancer

Abstract

Abstract Background Previous studies have indicated a predominance of passive decision-making styles among women with early-stage breast cancer in the UK offered a choice between breast-conserving surgery (BCS) and mastectomy. The aim of this study was to determine current decision-making styles and establish their association with operation choice and breast unit mastectomy rate. Methods A questionnaire survey was conducted among women from three specialist breast units representing high, medium and low case mix-adjusted mastectomy rates. Results Of 697 consecutive patients, 356 (51·1 per cent) completed the questionnaire, a mean of 6·9 (range 1·3–48·6) weeks after surgery. Some 262 women (73·6 per cent) underwent BCS and 94 (26·4 per cent) had a mastectomy. Some 218 patients (61·2 per cent) achieved their preferred decision-making style. The proportions of women achieving an active decision-making style were high, particularly for those choosing mastectomy (83 versus 58·0 per cent for BCS; P < 0·001) and in the high mastectomy rate unit (79·6 versus 53 and 52·2 per cent for medium and low rate units respectively; P < 0·001). Conclusion More women chose an active decision-making style than in previous UK studies. The provision of greater treatment selection autonomy to women suitable for BCS may not reduce mastectomy rates.