Rectal deformation management with IGRT in prostate radiotherapy: Can it be managed with rigid alignment alone?

Abstract

AbstractPurposeIt is challenging to achieve appropriate target coverage of the prostate with Image Guided Radiation Therapy (IGRT) while simultaneously constraining rectal doses within planned values when there is significant variability in rectal filling and shape. We investigated if rectum planning goals can be fulfilled using rigid CBCT‐based on‐board alignment to account for interfraction rectal deformations.MethodsDelivered rectal doses corresponding to prostate alignment (“PR”) and anterior rectum alignment (“AR”) for 239 daily treatments from 13 patients are reported. Rectal doses were estimated by rigidly mapping the planned dose on the daily CT derived from the daily CBCT according to respective alignment shifts. Rectum V95% (rV95%) was used for analyses.ResultsCompared to “PR”, “AR” alignment increased rV95% for an average of 34.4% across all patients. rV95% (cc) averaged over all fractions was significant from planning values for 10/13 patients for “PR” and for 9/13 for “AR”. 3/13 patients had reproducible anatomy. Of patients with non‐reproducible anatomy, three had dosimetrically more favorable, while seven had less favorable anatomies. Most shift differences (82.3%) between the “PR” and “AR” alignments larger than 2 mm resulted in rV95% changes larger than 2 cc. Most shift differences (82.2%) of 2 mm or less between the “PR” and “AR” alignments resulted in rV95% changes less than 2 cc. The average percentage of fractions among patients in which anterior or posterior shifts for “AR” and “PR” alignment was larger than the PTV margins was 9.1% (0.0%–37.5%) and 1.3% (0%–10%).ConclusionRectal deformation and subsequent inconsistent interfraction separation between prostate and rectal wall translate into anatomical changes that cannot always be mitigated with rigid alignment. If systematic differences exist due to a non‐reproducible planning anatomy, attempts to restore the planned rectal doses through anterior rectum alignment produce rather small improvements and may result in unacceptable target underdosage.