Optimal minimum MU for intensity‐modulated proton therapy with pencil‐beam scanning proton beams

Abstract

AbstractPurposeA higher minimum monitor unit (minMU) for pencil‐beam scanning proton beams in intensity‐modulated proton therapy is preferred for more efficient delivery. However, plan quality may be compromised when the minMU is too large.This study aimed to identify the optimal minMU (OminMU) to improve plan delivery efficiency while maintaining high plan quality.MethodsWe utilized clinical plans including six anatomic sites (brain, head and neck, breast, lung, abdomen, and prostate) from 23 patients previously treated with the Varian ProBeam system. The minMU of each plan was increased from the current clinical minMU of 1.1 to 3–24 MU depending on the daily prescribed dose (DPD). The dosimetric parameters of the plans were evaluated for consistency against a 1.1‐minMU plan for target coverage as well as organs‐at‐risk dose sparing. DPD/minMU was defined as the ratio of DPD to minMU (cGy/MU) to find the OminMU by ensuring that dosimetric parameters did not differ by >1% compared to those of the 1.1‐minMU plan.ResultsAll plans up to 5 minMU showed no significant dose differences compared to the 1.1‐minMU plan. Plan qualities remained acceptable when DPD/minMU ≥35 cGy/MU. This suggests that the 35 cGy/MU criterion can be used as the OminMU, which implies that 5 MU is the OminMU for a conventional fraction dose of 180 cGy. Treatment times were decreased by an average of 32% (max 56%, min 7%) and by an average of 1.6 min when the minMU was increased from 1.1 to OminMU.ConclusionA clinical guideline for OminMU has been established. The minMU can be increased by 1 MU for every 35 cGy of DPD without compromising plan quality for most cases analyzed in this study. Significant treatment time reduction of up to 56% was observed when the suggested OminMU is used.