“Water or not water: That is the question.” Analysis of costs and consumption of the operating theaters in a greener perspective

Abstract

AbstractObjectiveTo compare the amounts of water and plastic used in surgical hand washing with medicated soaps and with alcohol‐based products and to compare costs and consumption in a year, based on scheduled surgical activity.MethodThis retrospective study was carried out at Udine's Gynecology Operating Block from October to November 2022. We estimated the average amount of water with a graduated cylinder and the total cost of water usage based on euros/m3 indicated by the supplier; for each antiseptic agent we collected the data relevant to wash time, amount of water and product used per scrub, number of handscrubs made with every 500 mL bottle and cost of a single bottle. We put data into two hypothetical contexts, namely WHO guidelines and manufacturers' recommendations. Data were subjected to statistical analysis.ResultsThe daily amount of water using povidone‐iodine, chlorhexidine‐gluconate and alcohol‐based antiseptic agents was 187.6, 140.7 and 0 L/day (P value = 0.001), respectively; A total of 69 000 L/year of water would be saved if alcohol‐based products were routinely used. A single unit of an alcohol‐based product allows three times as many handscrubs as any other product (P value = 0.001) with consequent reduction in plastic packaging.ConclusionDespite the cost saving being negligible, choosing alcohol‐based handrub over medicated soap handrub – on equal antiseptic efficacy grounds ‐ could lead to a significant saving of water and plastic, thus making our operating theaters more environmentally friendly.