JAMES BUTTLE REVIEW: Quantifying the influence of forestry and forest disturbance on stream temperature: Methodologies and challenges

Abstract

AbstractStream temperature governs many aquatic ecosystem processes and plays a key role in determining the distribution of cold‐water amphibians and cool‐ and cold‐water fish, including salmonids. Decades of research have focused on the effects of forestry and forest disturbance on stream temperature, and new projects are underway or being planned in jurisdictions including the Provinces of Alberta and British Columbia, Canada, and Washington State, USA. The objective of this paper is to provide a critical review of methodologies employed in previous studies. The review initially focuses on the range of metrics used to quantify stream thermal regimes and the factors that control stream temperature variability in time and space, then focuses on sampling and analytical methodologies used to quantify stream temperature response to forestry activity and forest disturbance. Empirical methods include sampling in time, space, or both, and may or may not include pre‐ and post‐harvest data. Process‐based mechanistic and hybrid empirical‐mechanistic models have also been applied. The advantages and disadvantages of these approaches are discussed, and recommendations provided to support the design and execution of future studies.