Benign Phyllodes Tumors: Comparison of Prognosis among Three Different Surgical Approaches

Abstract

Purpose. To evaluate the prognosis of patients with benign phyllodes tumors (PTs) treated by different surgical methods and to explore the influencing factors of local recurrence. Methods. We retrospectively analyzed 215 benign PTs from 193 patients who underwent surgery at Chinese PLA General Hospital between October 2008 and December 2020. We stratified our analysis according to surgical factors and explored the clinicopathological factors to influence local recurrence. Results. Among 193 patients, a total of 17 (8.8%, 17/193) recurred during follow-up. There were 89 patients in the US-VAE group, of whom 6 (6.7%) recurred; 8 of 57 patients (14%) in the local lumpectomy group recurred, while 3 of 47 patients (6.4%) in the extended lumpectomy group recurred ( $P=0.252$ ). Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that tumor diameter, mitosis, and history of breast myoma were independent risk factors for tumor recurrence ( $P=0.005$ , $P=0.006$ , and $P=0.004$ , respectively). The intraoperative blood loss, operation time, and scar length of the US-VAE group were shorter than those of the other two groups ( $P<0.05$ ). Conclusion. Negative surgical margins of benign PTs can obtain similar prognosis as negative surgical margins >10 mm. Therefore, we recommend that a follow-up observation policy be adopted for patients with unexpected benign PTs, rather than unnecessary open surgical resection. Patients’ maximum tumor diameter, mitosis, and fibroadenoma history were independent predictors for recurrence of benign PTs.