Acupuncture Combined with Voice Training Improved Voice Function in Patients with Primary Muscular Tension Dysphonia (MTD): A Randomized, Three-Armed, Open-Label Clinical Trial

Abstract

Objective. This randomized controlled trial aimed to evaluate the clinical efficacy of acupuncture combined with voice training for treating patients with primary muscular tension dysphonia (MTD) (Qi stagnation and blood stasis type in traditional Chinese medicine). Methods. A total of 108 patients with primary MTD (Qi stagnation and blood stasis type) were recruited in this study. The participants were randomly divided into 3 equal groups: a test group and two control groups (control groups 1 and 2). An additional 38 participants without primary MTD were recruited as the healthy group. Control group 1 received acupuncture sessions 3 times per week on alternate days on the Hegu (LI 4), Taichong (LR 3), Open Voice No. 1 point, and Open Voice No. 2 points. Control group 2 received a 40-minute voice training session once weekly. The test group received both treatments. The total treatment course for all groups was 30 days. The healthy participants did not receive any interventions. The physiological and functional voice improvements after treatment were compared between all 3 MTD groups and healthy participants. The Voice Handicap Index (VHI-10), the VHI-10 emotional score, the Chinese Medicine Symptom Score Scale (TCM), and the Grade Roughness Breathiness Asthenia Strain (GRBAS) were used to evaluate the changes in the voice after treatment. A laryngeal muscle blood oxygen monitoring was used to measure the blood oxygen saturation (SO2) of the suprahyoid and infrahyoid muscles, and a stroboscopic laryngoscopy was used to measure the dysphonia severity index (DSI). Acoustic voice analysis was used to measure the maximum phonation time (MPT), the jitter, and the shimmer. Result. The SO2 levels of the laryngeal muscle were significantly higher in the healthy subjects than in pretreatment MTD patients and were correlated with the VHI-10 and DSI scores. A significant improvement in the physiological and functional scores, the total VHI-10, the GRBAS score, the voice acoustic analysis indices, MPT, jitter, shimmer, and DSI, was noted after treatment in all 3 MTD groups ( $P<0.05$ ). However, the posttreatment scores in the test group were significantly higher compared to control group 2, whose score were superior than that in control group 1 ( $P<0.05$ ). Both the test group and control group 1 showed a significant increase in the SO2 levels of the laryngeal muscles after treatment, where the test group had a higher elevation than control group 1. No significant difference was noted in the posttreatment SO2 of the laryngeal muscles in control group 2 ( $P>0.05$ ). Conclusion. Acupuncture monotherapy or in combination with voice training can reduce the anxiety emotion, relieve MTD-associated systemic symptoms, and increase the SO2 levels of the laryngeal muscle. This combination is a promising approach for the treatment of MTD. This trial is registered with ChiCTR2200061469.