Verifying proofs in constant depth

Abstract

In this paper we initiate the study of proof systems where verification of proofs proceeds by NC 0 circuits. We investigate the question which languages admit proof systems in this very restricted model. Formulated alternatively, we ask which languages can be enumerated by NC 0 functions. Our results show that the answer to this problem is not determined by the complexity of the language. On the one hand, we construct NC 0 proof systems for a variety of languages ranging from regular to NP complete. On the other hand, we show by combinatorial methods that even easy regular languages such as Exact-OR do not admit NC 0 proof systems. We also show that Majority does not admit NC 0 proof systems. Finally, we present a general construction of NC 0 proof systems for regular languages with strongly connected NFA's.