Adaptive sampling strategies for quickselects

Abstract

Quickselect with median-of-3 is largely used in practice and its behavior is fairly well understood. However, the following natural adaptive variant, which we call proportion-from-3 , had not been previously analyzed: “choose as pivot the smallest of the sample if the relative rank of the sought element is below 1/3, the largest if the relative rank is above 2/3, and the median if the relative rank is between 1/3 and 2/3.” We first analyze the average number of comparisons made when using proportion-from-2 and then for proportion-from-3. We also analyze ν-find, a generalization of proportion-from-3 with interval breakpoints at ν and 1-ν. We show that there exists an optimal value of ν and we also provide the range of values of ν where ν-find outperforms median-of-3. Then, we consider the average total cost of these strategies, which takes into account the cost of both comparisons and exchanges. Our results strongly suggest that a suitable implementation of ν-find could be the method of choice in a practical setting. We also study the behavior of proportion-from- s with s >3 and in particular we show that proportion-from- s -like strategies are optimal when s →∞.