Affiliation:
1. SUPREME COURT, KYIV, UKRAINE
Abstract
The aim: Establishing the forms of criminal liability in case of death of the patient and the presence of such a condition as the desire of the relatives of the deceased to reconcile with the subject of the criminal offense.
Materials and methods: In the course of the study, 62 court judgements were used. Comparative, systematic, analytic, and empiric research methods have been used in this research.
Results: The position of the victims – relatives of the deceased – has a direct influence on the choice of the form of criminal liability. A medical worker who is the subject of a criminal offense may reconcile with the relatives of the deceased patient and enter into a reconciliation agreement. It is the parties of the agreement who consent to the punishment and the possible exemption from it. At the same time, the court cannot exempt a medical worker from criminal liability in case of a patient’s death. This thesis is based on the fact that the possibility of such exemption is directly related to the reconciliation with the victims who are patients that were provided with medical service. Besides, death is a consequence that is irreversible.
Conclusions: The exemption from criminal liability according to the reconciliation of the guilty person with the victim in case of death of a patient is stated to be impossible. At the same time, the possibility of concluding a reconciliation agreement in this case has been established.
Reference17 articles.
1. 1. Antoniuk N.O. Kontseptsii rozuminnia kryminalnoi vidpovidalnosti [The concept of understanding criminal responsibility]. Chasopys Kyivskoho universytetu prava. 2019. №2. S.170-175 (in Ukrainian).
2. 2. Antoniuk N. Differentiation of criminal liability of medical professionals. Wiad Lek. 2020;73(12 p. II):2728-2732.
3. 3. Pizarro Carlos W. Perspectives in medical liability Rev Med Chil 2008Apr;136(4):539-43. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18769798/
4. 4. Gornostay A, Ivantsova A, Mykhailichenko T. Medical error and liability for it in some post-soviet countries (Belarus, Kazakhstan, Moldova, Ukraine). Wiad Lek. 2019;72(5 cz 1):877-882. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31175788/
5. 5. Ulsenheimer K. Medical expert assessment in criminal processes from the legal viewpoint Z Arztl Fortbild (Jena) 1996 Nov;90(7):574-81. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9064925/