1. *I worked on this paper during two summers as a visiting scholar at the University of Pittsburgh. I am grateful to Michael Thompson and the Pittsburgh Philosophy Department for hospitality and research support. I am also grateful for the research assistance of Sara Zizzo, funded by the University of Louisville's Vice President for Research. I read a truncated earlier version at the 2003 Central APA. I am grateful to Irfan Khawaja, Dan Farnham, and the audience, whose participation made for an extremely fruitful session. Karen Christopher, Kristen Hessler, David Imbroscio, Eileen John, Linda Radzik, and Leigh Viner all read drafts and provided incisive comments and helpful suggestions, as did Bob Goodin and three anonymous referees. Finally, I am grateful to Cheshire Calhoun, Amanda LeDuke, and Nancy Potter for discussions that significantly helped me develop my thinking on this issue.
2. Symposium: Diversity & Civic Solidarity Diversity, Solidarity and Civic Friendship
3. 2Sandra Lee Bartky, "Sympathy and solidarity," in Bartky,'Sympathy and Solidarity' and other Essays(Lanham, Md.: Rowman & Littlefield, 2002), pp. 69-89, at p. 74. The sentence concludes, ". not to arrange one's life so as to share it." Bartky makes this point in criticism of Simone Weil.