Affiliation:
1. Department of Political Science University of Florida Gainesville Florida USA
2. Department of Political Science Oklahoma State University Stillwater Oklahoma USA
Abstract
AbstractIn the study of the policy diffusion process, scholars have found that states adopt policies to remain competitive with one another over economic resources. But the rapid spread of Name, Image, and Likeness (NIL) policies, which treat college athletes as professionals, is not readily explained by economic competition nor other diffusion mechanisms. The NIL phenomenon points to a new dimension of competition between the states, which is more closely tied to states protecting or enhancing their reputations than it is to directly accruing economic resources. To test if NIL spread as the result of athletic reputation competition, we model the adoption of NIL legislation as a function of internal characteristics (i.e. number, value, and ranking of college football programs) and interstate dynamics (i.e. actions of football, conference, and Power 5 competitors). We test the effect of these measures alongside traditional diffusion indicators, finding that both internal and interstate indicators of athletic competition drive states to adopt and implement NIL. NIL is important to study as it has changed the landscape of amateur sports, as well as our scholarly understanding of policy diffusion in the American federal system, specifically broadening our conceptualization of the competition mechanism and developing customized measures of it.
Subject
Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law,Public Administration,Sociology and Political Science
Reference56 articles.
1. Conditional tax competition in American states
2. Welfare and the Multifaceted Decision to Move
3. Baker Matt.2022.“Florida ‘can't Compete’ with Other States in NIL. Here's What that Means and Why it Matters.”Tampa Bay Times.https://www.tampabay.com/sports/seminoles/2022/02/14/florida‐cant‐compete‐with‐other‐states‐in‐nil‐heres‐what‐that‐means‐and‐why‐it‐matters/
4. Balasaygun Kaitlin.2022.“In the College Sports Pay Era Female Athletes are Emerging as Big Economic Winners.”CNBC.https://www.cnbc.com/2022/10/15/that‐nike‐bronny‐james‐nil‐deal‐was‐a‐big‐deal‐for‐women‐too.html
5. A Strategic Theory of Policy Diffusion via Intergovernmental Competition