A prospective case series on the efficacy of a cross‐linked collagen matrix to increase buccal soft tissue thickness at large edentulous gaps: One‐year results

Abstract

AbstractObjectiveThe objective of this study is to assess profilometric changes following soft tissue augmentation with a cross‐linked porcine‐derived collagen matrix (CMX) at large edentulous gaps of at least two units.Materials and methodsSystemically healthy, nonsmoking patients with a large edentulous gap of at least two units demonstrating a horizontal soft tissue defect, were enrolled in a prospective case series. Soft tissue augmentation was performed in a one‐stage approach with a 6 mm thick CMX at the time of implant placement. The primary outcome was the change in buccal soft tissue profile (BSP) at a mesial, central, and distal area of interest (AOI) up to 1 year when compared to the preoperative situation based on superimposed digital surface models. Secondary outcomes included the horizontal dimension of the soft tissue defect, complications, and marginal bone loss (MBL).ResultsFifteen patients (eight females; mean age 58.73 years) were enrolled and 13 could be re‐assessed at 1‐year follow‐up. The mean linear increase in BSP at 1 year was 0.66 mm (98.3% CI: 0.37–0.94), 0.80 mm (98.3% CI: 0.39–1.22), and 0.69 mm (98.3% CI: 0.32–1.06) at the mesial, central, and distal AOI, respectively. Substantial shrinkage of about 75% was observed in all areas between augmentation and 1‐year follow‐up. Even though 11 of 13 sites were fully augmented immediately postoperative, a soft tissue defect recurred in all sites at 1‐year follow‐up with a mean deficit of 2.30 mm. Altogether, 25% of the original soft tissue defect was eliminated by soft tissue augmentation. CMX was safe since no postoperative complications occurred and MBL was limited (0.70 mm).ConclusionCMX is efficacious for horizontal soft tissue augmentation at large edentulous gaps. However, considerable graft resorption may be expected, and the clinical relevance of the augmentation may be questionable since all patients demonstrated a recurring and considerable soft tissue defect 1 year after surgery.