Why do patients transition between orthodontic appliances? A qualitative analysis of patient decision‐making

Abstract

AbstractObjectivesTo gain an in‐depth understanding of patients' decision‐making processes when choosing to transition to a different orthodontic appliance (OA).MethodsThis was a retrospective qualitative study using one‐on‐one in‐depth semi‐structured interviews. Patients were recruited through purposive convenience sampling. Participants who had elected to transition from and to one of these OAs: metal brackets, tooth‐coloured brackets, or clear aligners before the end of treatment were recruited. Recruitment ceased when data saturation was achieved. The interviews were audio‐recorded, transcribed verbatim and analysed using thematic analysis.ResultsTwenty‐three adult participants (12 males, 11 females) with their ages ranging from 18 to 52 years were interviewed. The analysis of the data revealed that participants perceived two reasons for the transition: (1) insufficient initial information and (2) evolving life circumstances and personal style. Data analysis of participants who expressed a notable discrepancy between their expectations and the reality of the OA they chose revolved around three themes: (a) health benefits and threats, (b) personal control, and (c) financial considerations. Data analysis of participants who described transitioning between OAs due to changes in personal circumstances and style, revealed two themes: (a) change in personal values and motivations and (b) change in social and psychological influence.ConclusionsThis qualitative study highlighted the complex multifactorial nature of patient decision‐making when choosing and transitioning OAs. Orthodontists can benefit from understanding these factors to engage in thorough patient‐centered counselling, provide tailored treatment recommendations, and optimize the choice of appliances.