The real unmet need: A multifactorial approach for identifying sensitized kidney candidates with low access to transplant

Abstract

AbstractBackgroundAt the start of 2020, the kidney waiting list consisted of 2526 candidates with a calculated panel reactive antibody (CPRA) of 99.9% or greater, a cohort demonstrated in published research to have meaningfully lower than average access to transplantation even under the revised kidney allocation system (KAS).MethodsThis was a retrospective analysis of US kidney registrations using data from the OPTN [Reference (https://optn.transplant.hrsa.gov/data/about‐data/)]. The period‐prevalent study cohort consisted of US kidney‐alone registrations who waited at least 1 day between April 1, 2016, when HLA DQ‐Alpha and DP‐Beta unacceptable antigen data became available in OPTN data collection, to December 31, 2019. Poisson rate regression was used to model deceased donor kidney transplant rates per active year waiting and using an offset term to account for differential at‐risk periods. Median time to transplant was estimated for each IRR group using the Kaplan–Meier method. Sensitivity analyses were included to address geographic variation in supply‐to‐demand ratios and differences in dialysis time or waiting time.ResultsIn this study, we found 1597 additional sensitized (CPRA 50–<99.9%) candidates with meaningfully lower than average access to transplant when simultaneously taking into account CPRA and other factors. In combination with CPRA, candidate blood type, Estimated Post‐Transplant Survival Score (EPTS), and presence of other antibody specificities beyond those in the current, 5‐locus CPRA were found to influence the likelihood of transplant.ConclusionIn total, this suggests approximately 4100 sensitized candidates are on the waiting list who represent a community of disadvantaged patients who may benefit from progressive therapies and interventions to facilitate incompatible transplantation. Though associated with higher risks, such interventions may nevertheless be more attractive than remaining on dialysis with the associated accumulation of mortality risk over time.