A prospective randomized comparative trial of pediatric C‐MAC D‐blade video laryngoscope with McCoy direct laryngoscope for intubation in children posted for elective surgical procedures under general anesthesia

Abstract

AbstractBackgroundPediatric airway management requires careful clinical evaluation and experienced execution due to anatomical, physiological, and developmental considerations. Video laryngoscopy in pediatric airways is a developing area of research, with recent data suggesting that video laryngoscopes are better than standard Macintosh blades. Specifically, there is a paucity of literature on the advantages of the C‐MAC D‐blade compared to the McCoy direct laryngoscope.MethodsAfter Ethics Committee approval, 70 American Society of Anesthesiologists physical status 1 and 2 children aged 4–12 years scheduled for elective surgery under general anesthesia were recruited. Patients were randomly allocated to intubation using a C‐MAC video laryngoscope size 2 D‐blade (Group 1) and a McCoy laryngoscope size 2 blade (Group 2). The Intubation Difficulty Scale (IDS) for ease of intubation was the primary outcome, while Cormack–Lehane grades, duration of laryngoscopy and intubation, hemodynamic responses, and incidence of any airway complications were secondary outcomes.ResultsBoth groups were comparable in terms of patient characteristics. The median (IQR) Intubation Difficulty Scale (IDS) score was better but was statistically nonsignificant with C‐MAC (0 [0–0] vs. 0 [0–2], p = .055). The glottic views were superior (CL grade I in 32/35 vs. 23/35, p = .002), and the time to best glottic view (6 s [5–7] vs. 8.0 s [6–10], p = .006) was lesser in the C‐MAC D‐blade group while the total duration of intubation was comparable (20 s [16–22] vs. 18 s [15–22], p = .374). All the patients could be successfully intubated on the first attempt. None of the patients had any complications.ConclusionThe C‐MAC video laryngoscope size 2 D‐blade provided faster and better glottic visualization but similar intubation difficulty compared to McCoy size 2 laryngoscope in children. The shorter time to achieve glottic view demonstrated with the C‐MAC failed to translate into a shorter total duration of intubation when compared to the McCoy laryngoscope attributable to a pronounced curvature of the D‐blade.