Risk perception in pregnancy: Patient‐physician discrepancies, information consumption, and mental health outcomes

Abstract

AbstractBackgroundLittle is known about the scope, causes, or consequences of risk overestimation. Our aim was to assess whether risk perceptions in pregnancy are heightened for a range of behaviors, related to consumption of health information, and associated with mental health indices.MethodsOne hundred and fifty members of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists were invited to participate in a patient–physician study, and 37% returned surveys. Physicians (n = 73) and prenatal patients (n = 388) rated the perceived safety of exposure to 40 behaviors during pregnancy. A subset of prenatal patients completed a postpartum follow‐up survey (n = 103).ResultsStatistical comparison of means indicated that patients overestimated the risk of 30 behaviors. Anchoring patient ratings against average physician ratings, 87.8% of total discrepancy scores reflected net risk overestimation. Greater risk overestimation was associated with higher consumption of pregnancy‐related health information, but was not associated with anxiety or depression symptoms.ConclusionsRisk perceptions may be heightened across a range of behaviors during pregnancy, even when empirical evidence of risk is absent. Information consumption could be associated with risk estimation, but causality and directionality have not been established. Further research on risk perceptions could have implications for prenatal care.