1. Cruikshank Kate in her review of Peter Metz, Herbartianism as a Paradigm for Professional and School Reform (Bern: Peter Lang, 1992) has drawn attention to a similar dissatisfaction with “the catechetical mode of teaching” in Germany. See History of Education Quarterly 36 (Fall 1996): 336. In a study of teachers in Queensland one-room schools in the period 1920–50, a common complaint of school inspectors in their annual report was that teachers continued to use the question and answer catechetical form of teaching. Associated with an instrumentary educational approach, the inspectors described it as being “mechanical” and “un-intellectual.” See Meadmore Peter “Hard Times, Expedient Measures: Women Teachers in Queensland Rural Schools, 1920–50,” History of Education 28:4 (1999): 435–447.
2. Ibid., 203.
3. New South Wales Educational Gazette, 13:12 (1904): 286.