Nurses' professional discretion in the purchaser‐provider split in home care in Norway

Abstract

AbstractAimTo explore how nurses' professional discretion is operationalized in home care services that follow a purchaser–provider organization in Norway.DesignA qualitative descriptive study.MethodsSemi‐structured interviews with open‐ended questions were used, and data were collected from in‐depth interviews with 15 registered nurses working in home care in four Norwegian local authority areas between April and November 2020. Braun and Clark's six‐step analysis was used to analyse the empirical data.ResultsThe analysis yielded two main themes, namely ‘The purchaser's instructions: facilitating and constraining care’ and ‘Professional discretion meets the purchaser–provider organisation of healthcare,’ with five associated codes.ConclusionNurses are dependent on an organizational framework due to the complexity of health care services and the number of tasks involved. At the same time, they perform considerable compensatory work and need the ability to be flexible to enable this work and to perform actions related to the unforeseen needs of individual patients or those involving professional discretion.ImpactThe purchaser–provider model both facilitates and constrains nursing practice and professional responsibility in home nursing. Home nursing services need to be well organized because of their complexity and the wide variety of tasks they involve. In this context, the element of constraint is associated with the need for flexibility and professional discretion. Despite a strict framework, the nurses perform additional and compensatory tasks. Reforms inspired by ‘New Public Management,’ such as the purchaser–provider split, limit the workload for nurses; however, there is still a need to exercise discretion. The findings of this study may help home care managers and health policy‐makers understand the interaction between management logic and health care logic, leading to a more appropriate organization of health care services where the nurses, as actors, gain more trust.ImplicationsThis study highlights home care nurses' opportunities to exercise discretion in an organizational framework that strives towards standardization. The nurses' ability to exercise discretion is important for individual and holistic patient care. At the same time, an organizational framework is needed because nurses cannot attend to all the needs the patients may have, as this will overload both home health services and the nurses.