Towards new design rainfall profiles for the United Kingdom
-
Published:2023-10-25
Issue:
Volume:
Page:
-
ISSN:1753-318X
-
Container-title:Journal of Flood Risk Management
-
language:en
-
Short-container-title:J Flood Risk Management
Author:
Villalobos Herrera Roberto1ORCID,
Blenkinsop Stephen1,
Guerreiro Selma B.1,
Dale Murray2,
Faulkner Duncan2ORCID,
Fowler Hayley J.13
Affiliation:
1. School of Engineering Newcastle University Newcastle upon Tyne UK
2. JBA Consulting Skipton UK
3. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research Newcastle University Newcastle upon Tyne UK
Abstract
AbstractThe Flood Studies Report (FSR) summer and winter design profiles are a key component of rainfall design guidance in the United Kingdom (UK). We have examined the rainfall profiles of over 70,000 extreme rainfall events with the original FSR profile methodology. This analysis reveals that rainfall profiles change with rainstorm duration but not season, contradicting one of the key assumptions in current UK rainfall design guidance. By using a method that does not artificially generate symmetrical and centred profiles we show that profile shapes are highly variable and strongly related to event duration and magnitude. Short events tend towards front‐loaded profiles, while heavy long‐duration events tend towards centred profile shapes. Finally, manual, automatic and mixed methods of deriving new design profiles for use in the UK were trialled, with consistent results. These could be used to derive new design profiles to supersede the FSR profiles. Notably, peak intensities in observed profiles and trialled summary profiles often exceeded those found in both FSR profiles. We conclude that current design profile guidance for the UK fails to account for the observed variability in event profile shapes and peak intensities and may lead to significant under‐ or over‐design of flood risk management solutions.
Funder
FP7 Ideas: European Research Council
Natural Environment Research Council
Universidad de Costa Rica
Subject
Water Science and Technology,Safety, Risk, Reliability and Quality,Geography, Planning and Development,Environmental Engineering
Reference53 articles.
1. The influence of temporal patterns on surface runoff hydrographs;Ball J. E.;Journal of Hydrology,1994
2. Bonnin G. M. Martin D. Lin B. Parzybok T. Yekta M. &Riley D.(2011).NOAA Atlas 14—Precipitation‐Frequency Atlas of the United States(Vol. 1).https://www.weather.gov/media/owp/oh/hdsc/docs/Atlas14_Volume1.pdf