Estimating catch curve mortality based on relative return rates of coded wire tagged lake trout in US waters of Lake Huron

Abstract

We estimated total mortality using catch curves based on relative return rates (RRs) of coded wire tagged lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush) in US waters of Lake Huron. RR was calculated as age-specific CPUE per million of fish stocked. Annual mortality for the late 1990s through early 2000s was estimated as 38% from the 1991–1995 year classes, with an effective age range of 5–10 years, and then was estimated as 24% for the post-2000 period from the 1996–2009 year classes. The two estimates from simple catch curve regressions based on average RR at age values were the same as from a mixed model with individual RR values from all stocking events. These two estimates were also comparable to the findings from statistical catch-at-age assessments with fundamentally different assumptions. Our approach is not constrained by the assumption that the expected recruitment is a constant over time and thus has the advantage to use multiple observations on each age from multiple cohorts. Our approach has broad applicability to aquatic ecosystems in which multiple mark-and-release events of fish stocking have been implemented.