Marine Phytoplankton Photosynthesis as a Function of Light Intensity: A Comparison of Methods

Abstract

An apparatus is described in which the constant for exponential algal growth has been determined as a function of light at controlled temperature. Studies were made of bacteria-free cultures of Skeletonema costatum and Dunaliella tertiolecta grown at the optimum temperature for cell division in media with and without adequate nitrate and phosphate. Less complete studies were made of the behaviour of Monochrysis lutheri and Amphidinium carteri. In all experiments the growth constants were determined at known light intensities, expressed in the energy units, langlies/minute, using light of a known spectral distribution similar to sunlight shining through a few metres of coastal sea water.Growth constants were determined for the following processes: increase of cellular carbon, chlorophylls a, b or c, carotenoids, cell numbers and photosynthesis measured both by oxygen evolution (net and gross) and by the uptake of C-14 labelled carbonate.The rate of maximum photosynthesis occurred when the illumination reached about 0.1 ly/min and little or no light inhibition occurred when the intensity was increased to as high as 0.4 ly/min. Respiration was about 10% of maximum gross photosynthesis. This fraction increased when cells were nitrogen deficient but decreased in phosphate deficient cultures because a phosphate shortage inhibited respiration more severely than photosynthesis.Gross photosynthesis at low light intensities was proportional to the total number of molecules of all plant pigments added together, irrespective of species or of culturing conditions. By contrast, the rate of maximum gross photosynthesis was poorly related to pigment composition, the best correspondence being with the amount of chlorophyll a in the cultures.The uptake rate of C-14 varied with time. There was an apparent "leakage" of labelled organic matter which eventually reached a near-equilibrium with 14CO2 uptake, after which the C-14 method measured the production of particulate carbon but not necessarily net or gross photosynthesis. The rate of particulate carbon production was the same as that of cell division but about 40% less than net photosynthesis in cultures of Skeletonema. Agreement between C-14 rates and net photosynthesis was better in cool-white fluorescent light than in the imitation submarine sunlight used in this work. At high light intensities there was apparently no excretion from Dunaliella "shade" cells but when these became changed to "sun" cells they behaved more like Skeletonema.Various observations are recorded of the effect of growth conditions on cell composition, especially with regard to pigments.The relatively low C-14 rates found with Skeletonema costatum may be explicable in part by an abnormally low counting efficiency for this species even when present as a "weightless" source but the problem requires further study.