Effects of geographic information system vector–raster–vector data conversion on landscape indices

Abstract

The effects of geographic information system (GIS) data conversion on several polygon-and landscape-level indices were evaluated by using a GIS vegetation coverage from eastern Oregon, U.S.A. A vector–raster–vector conversion process was used to examine changes in GIS data. This process is widely used for data input (digital scanning of vector maps) and somewhat less widely used for data conversion (output of GIS data to specific formats). Most measures were sensitive to the grid cell size used in the conversion process. At the polygon level, using the conversion process with grid cell sizes of 3.05, 6.10, and 10 m produced relatively small changes to the original polygons in terms of ln(polygon area), ln(polygon perimeter), and 1/(fractal dimension). When grid cell size increased to 20 and 30 m, however, polygons were significantly different (p < 0.05) according to these polygon-level indices. At the landscape level, the number of polygons, polygon size coefficient of variation (CV), and edge density increased, while mean polygon size and an interspersion and juxtaposition index (IJI) decreased. The youngest and oldest age-class polygons followed the trends of overall landscape only in terms of number of polygons, mean polygon size, CV, and IJI. One major side effect of the conversion process was that many small polygons were produced in and around narrow areas of the original polygons. An alleviation process (referred to as the dissolving process) was used to dissolve the boundaries between similarly attributed polygons. When we used the dissolving process, the rate of change for landscape-level indices slowed; although the number of polygons and CV still increased with larger grid cell sizes, the increase was less than when the dissolving process was not used. Mean polygon size, edge density, and fractal dimension decreased after use of the dissolving process. Trends for the youngest and oldest age-class polygons were similar to those for the total landscape, except that IJI was greater for these age-classes than for the total landscape.