Proppants, We Still Don't Need No Proppants - A Perspective of Several Operators

Abstract

Abstract In SPE 38611 "Proppants, We Don't Need No Proppants" data showed that fracture treatments using treated water and very low proppant concentrations (waterfracs) were very successful in the East Texas Cotton Valley sandstone. The paper presented limited initial results from one operator in one field. Following this paper a more comprehensive set of production comparisons of wells completed with standard frac jobs and waterfracs since 1996 for several different operators in the East Texas area are presented. Analysis of offset comparisons, economics, and other benefits are described from the aspect of several different operators. Conclusions will point out the cost savings and the ability to exploit marginal reserves with this technique. There will also be a perspective from each operator. The waterfrac technique has led to widespread discussions among many operators in various tight gas plays. Many operators are experimenting with the technique and experiencing excellent results. This technique is a major contribution to the reduction in completion costs in wells that must be hydraulically fractured. The industry has experienced a major inflation of well construction costs and this technique will be of paramount importance in our efforts to keep costs down in order to continue to develop tight gas reserves. Techniques such as these require many months of production in order to analyze to determine the actual results. Several techniques and the perspectives of several operators and how they make these important decisions will be presented here. P. 497