Theoretical Investigations into the Role of Aryl Nitrenium Ions' Stability on Their Mutagenic Potential

Abstract

By using Mulliken and Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) methods based on the density functional theory (DFT), partial charges of exocyclic nitrogen atoms were calculated for nitrenium ions formed from 201 known drugs and 50 Ames positive (mutagenic) compounds containing aryl amine and nitro moieties. The statistical difference of the partial charges was analysed based on the hypothesis that the mutagens have a more negative charge on their exocyclic nitrogen atom resulting in stable nitrenium ions, and thus a longer lifetime to react selectively with DNA; whereas known drugs are not in general mutagenic and therefore have a relatively more positive partial charge. The nitrenium ions with 1° amine parent compounds did not show a statistical difference between drugs and mutagens based on the Mulliken charges. A slight difference was observed in the NBO data where the drugs have more negative partial charge on their exocyclic nitrogen atoms compared with the mutagens. Interestingly, nitrenium ions with aryl nitro drugs as their parent compounds have more negative charge on the exocyclic nitrogen compared with the other drug classes. Aryl nitro drugs are relatively scarce and are often linked to genotoxicity, which fits with the hypotheses proposed. These results indicate that other physical properties besides the stability of the nitrenium ions are important to determine the mutagenic potential of aryl amine and nitro containing compounds.