Mineralogical control on physically protected soil organic matter in a neotropical moist forest

Abstract

Context Minerals and organic matter physically associate in many soils, yet the precise nature, either via a hierarchy of aggregate particles or by build-up of organo–mineral associations, remains obscure, especially in tropical forest environments. Aims We investigated physically protected organic matter by comparing soils with contrasting parent material, topography, and pedogenesis, but with similar tropical moist forest on Barro Colorado Island in the lowlands of Panama. Methods Bulk soil from 10 sites was separated by size into free-floating particles, macroaggregates (>250 μm), microaggregates (53–250 μm), and <53-μm particles. A subsample of macroaggregates was disintegrated and separated into coarse particles (>250 μm), occluded microaggregates, and occluded <53-μm particles. Concentrations and natural abundance of stable isotopes for carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) were determined for each fraction, and ratios (C:N, stable isotopes) were used to characterise organic matter for each fraction. Key results Macroaggregates were the largest fraction of bulk soil (71%) and were 15% greater in kaolinite- than smectite-dominated soils. Macroaggregates were composed of coarse particles (14%), occluded microaggregates (62%), and occluded <53-μm particles (24%). Concentrations of C and N widely varied among fractions but the variation was not related to clay mineralogy. The C:N ratio and stable N isotope ratio indicated more decomposed organic matter in kaolinite- than smectite-dominated soils. Conclusions and implications Macroaggregates composed of plant detritus and microaggregates in the Barro Colorado Island soils imply that the aggregate hierarchy route ultimately protects soil organic matter in this tropical forest environment.