State and Businessin the Arbitrazh (Commercial) Litigation-Reference-Cited by-同舟云学术

State and Businessin the Arbitrazh (Commercial) Litigation

Published:2014-06-20 Issue:6 Volume: Page:40-62
ISSN:0042-8736
Container-title:Voprosy Ekonomiki
language:
Short-container-title:Vopr. èkon.

Author:

Titaev K.¹,Dzmitryieva A.¹,Chetverikova I.¹

Affiliation:

1. Institute for the Rule of Law, European University at St. Petersburg (Russia)

Abstract

This article seeks to answer the question whether Russian Arbitrazh (Commercial) courts tend to decide cases in favor of defendant versus plaintiff or state versus business. We have found that courts favor business entities in civil cases, while in administrative cases courts take decisions in favor of governmental bodies other things being equal. In addition, the plaintiff bias persists regardless of the type of the process. However, the plaintiff bias decreases with the rise of the case complexity. The article is based on the regression analysis of a random sample of 10 000 cases decided by the Russian Arbitrazh (commercial) courts in 2007-2011.

Publisher

NP Voprosy Ekonomiki

Subject

Economics and Econometrics,Finance

Reference23 articles.

1. Volkov V. (2012). Introduction // How Judges Make Decisions. The Empirical Studies of Law / V. Volkov (ed.). Moscow: Statut. P. 3—17.

2. Volkov V., Paneyakh E., Titaev K. (2010). Deadweight Loss from State Induced Petty Cases in Arbitrazh (Commercial) Court. St. Petersburg: Institute for the Rule of Law, European University at St. Petersburg.

3. Dzmitryieva A., Titaev K., Chetverikova I. (2012). Russian Arbitrazh (Commercial) Courts. A Statistical Study / K. Titaev (ed.). St. Petersburg: Institute for the Rule of Law, European University at St. Petersburg.

4. Makarov I. (2003). The Reform of the Arbitration Justice // Otechestvennye Zapiski. No 2. P. 271—279.

5. Titaev K. (2011a). The Practice of the Russian Arbitrazh (Commercial) Courts. A Sociological View // Law and Law Enforcement in Russia: Interdisciplinary Studies / V. Volkov (ed.). Moscow: Statut. P. 116—137.

Cited by 1 articles. 订阅此论文施引文献订阅此论文施引文献，注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献，订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献

1. Protection of Russian industrial companies from violent pressure on business: The effectiveness of the judicial mechanism;Voprosy Ekonomiki;2020-03-10