Long-Term Outcome for Primary Papillomas of the Lacrimal Drainage System

Abstract

Purpose: To report long-term outcomes after surgery for primary benign papillomas of the lacrimal drainage system. Methods: Retrospective review of patients with primary lacrimal drainage system papillomas, first seen between 1984 and 2021, but excluding lesions with sino-nasal origin or malignant histology. Patients were categorized by tumor histology (squamous, transitional, and mixed cell) and growth pattern (exophytic, endophytic, or mixed). Results: Thirty patients (18 female; 60%) presented at a mean age of 46.1 years (12–79 years). Over an average follow-up of 10.4 years, 30% of patients experienced recurrence, with rates differing slightly by growth pattern: 25% for exophytic tumors and 40% for endophytic and mixed-pattern tumors (p = 0.431). The overall 5-year recurrence-free survival was 67% (± 9% standard error), this being slightly higher for exophytic lesions (75% ± 10%) as compared to 48% (± 19%) for tumors with an endophytic component (p = 0.370). No cases of malignant transformation were observed, and the tumor type at recurrence matched the initial diagnosis. Conclusion: Primary benign papillomas of the lacrimal drainage system have a long-term recurrence rate of about one-third, with a higher frequency in those exhibiting an endophytic growth pattern. The study highlights the importance of prolonged surveillance for recurrence, especially for endophytic and mixed growth pattern tumors, and for the potential to undergo malignant transformation. The results support the effectiveness of endoscopic surgical excision or laser thermos-ablation in managing recurrent lacrimal drainage system papillomas after dacryocystorhinostomy.