Luck, an Inquisitive Mind, and Opportunities: Lessons Learned: A Blinded Study of Pulse Oximetry before It Became a Standard of Care

Abstract

A Single-blind Study of Pulse Oximetry in Children. By CJ Coté, EA Goldstein, MA Cote, DC Hoaglin, and JF Ryan. Anesthesiology 1988; 68:184–8. Reprinted with permission.Oxygen saturation determined by pulse oximetry was monitored in 152 pediatric surgical patients divided into two groups. In one group, the oximeter data and alarms were available (N = 76) to the anesthesia team, and, in the other group, these data were unavailable (N = 76). A trained observer recorded all intraoperative hypoxic episodes and informed the anesthesia team of all major events (i.e., oxygen saturation 85% or less for 30 s or more; Pao2, approximately 52 mmHg). Thirty-five major events occurred: 24 in the unavailable group, and 11 in the available group (P = 0.021). A greater number of major events occurred in children 2 yr or younger (P = 0.013). Hypoxic events diagnosed by the oximeter, but not by the anesthesiologist, were more frequent in the unavailable group (13) than in the available group (5; P = 0.0495). American Society of Anesthesiologists (Schaumburg, Illinois) Physical Status III and IV patients were more likely to suffer a major event (P = 0.009 available, 0.006 unavailable). The pulse oximeter diagnosed hypoxemia before the signs and symptoms of hypoxemia were apparent (i.e., before observed cyanosis or bradycardia). Major hypoxic events were unrelated to duration of anesthesia. Major events were evenly distributed among induction, maintenance, and awakening from anesthesia; a greater number of hypoxic events occurred during induction in the unavailable group (P = 0.031). No morbidity was documented in any patient who suffered a hypoxic event. More patients experienced borderline oxygenation in room air at the end of anesthesia (90% saturation or less) in the unavailable group (12 of 60) than in the available group (3 of 57; P = 0.009). The authors conclude that pulse oximetry, in contrast to changes in vital signs, does provide an early warning of developing hypoxemia in anesthetized children.