Exploring Colorectal Cancer Screening Reach Among United States Veterans: Analyzing Clinical, Sociodemographic, and Social Determinants of Health-Based Patient Factors Across Screening Methods

Abstract

Introduction: Mailed fecal immunochemical testing (mFIT), in-clinic FIT (cFIT), and colonoscopy are believed to reach distinct patient populations. This study aims to evaluate this belief. Methods: Sociodemographic, clinical, and social determinants of health (SDOH) characteristics of 201 patients completing mFIT, 203 patients completing cFIT, and 74 patients completing colonoscopy at a Northeastern United States Veterans Affairs center from August 2023 to January 2024 were compared using descriptive statistics, χ2, and ANOVA tests. Results: Patients completing mFIT (P=0.003) and cFIT (P=0.001) were older than those completing colonoscopy. mFIT patients had more private health insurance as compared with cFIT (P<0.0001) patients. Patients completing colonoscopy had higher average disability ratings as compared with cFIT patients (P<0.0001). mFIT (P<0.0001) and colonoscopy (P<0.0001) patients had more time elapsed since their last primary care visit as compared with cFIT patients. mFIT patients had lower rates of mental health disorders as compared with colonoscopy (P<0.0001) and cFIT (P<0.0001) patients. cFIT patients had higher rates of past stool test use as compared with mFIT (P<0.0001) and colonoscopy (P<0.0001) patients. mFIT patients had lower rates of past colonoscopy completion as compared with cFIT (P<0.0001) and colonoscopy (P<0.0001) patients. There were no significant differences in SDOH domains among patients completing each of the screening methods. Conclusion: While each of the screening methods reaches a different patient population, mFIT does not reach a substantially more vulnerable population compared with cFIT and colonoscopy, highlighting the need for improvements in mFIT outreach.