The Value of Liver Biopsy and Histology in Liver Disease Diagnosis and Patient Care—a Pragmatic Prospective Clinical Practice Study

Abstract

Goals: We aimed to examine the correlation of pre-biopsy clinical diagnosis with hepatic histopathology. Background: Liver biopsy provides histologic information and informs physicians about the underlying clinical disease. We hypothesized that expert physicians’ pre-biopsy clinical diagnoses may obviate the need for histopathological diagnosis. Study Methods: Patients undergoing liver biopsy to investigate a liver diagnosis were prospectively identified. In the 80 patients included, an anonymous validated questionnaire inquiring about the most likely clinical diagnosis and liver disease stage was completed prospectively by hepatologists before biopsy performance. Results: The most common pre-biopsy diagnoses were alcoholic liver disease (19 diagnoses), followed by non-alcoholic steatohepatitis and autoimmune hepatitis (18 each). Overall, the predicted histologic diagnosis was the same as the histologic diagnosis in 51/80 patients (64%), and thus a new liver disease diagnosis was made in 36% of patients. The diagnosis with the greatest pre-biopsy and post-biopsy diagnosis discrepancy was autoimmune hepatitis, with the correct diagnosis being predicted in 6/18 (33%) of patients (other diagnoses included the following: non-alcoholic steatohepatitis/non-alcoholic fatty liver disease (4), alcoholic liver disease (3), drug-induced liver injury (3), others (2)). For fibrosis staging, when grouped as no fibrosis (F0), fibrosis (F1-F3), or cirrhosis (F4), the fibrosis stage was correctly predicted in 68% of patients (54/80). Notably, 7 patients (9%) who were initially thought to have no or early-stage fibrosis had F4 fibrosis, and 6/80 (8%) patients who were considered to have a liver disease diagnosis before their biopsy had normal histology. Conclusions: Although hepatology experts often predict the correct underlying liver disease diagnosis, histopathological diagnoses different from expected are common.