Quantifying partial volume effect in SPECT and planar imaging: optimizing region of interest for activity concentration estimation in different sphere sizes

Abstract

Introduction To quantify the partial volume effect in single photon emission tomography (SPECT) and planar images of Carlson phantom as well as providing an optimum region of interest (ROI) required to more accurately estimate the activity concentration for different sphere sizes. Methods 131I solution with the 161.16 kBq/ml concentration was uniformly filled into the different spheres of Carlson phantom (cold background condition) with the diameters of 7.3, 9.2, 11.4, 14.3, 17.9, 22.4 and 29.9 mm, and there was no background activity. In the hot background condition, the spheres were filled with the solution of 131I with the 1276.5 kBq/ml addition to the background activity concentration of 161.16 kBq/ml in all the phantoms. The spheres were mounted inside the phantom and underwent SPECT and planar images. ROI was drawn closely on the boundary of each sphere image and it was extended to extract the true count. Results In the cold background condition, the recovery coefficient (RC) value for SPECT images ranged between 0.8 and 1.03. However, in planar imaging, the RC value was 0.72 for the smallest sphere size and it increased for larger spheres until 0.98 for 29.9 mm. In the hot background condition, the RC value for sphere diameters larger than 20 mm was overestimated more than in the cold background condition. The ROI/size required to more accurately determine activity concentration for the cold background ranged from 1.18 to 2.7. However, in the hot background condition, this ratio varied from 1.34 to 4.05. Conclusion In the quantification of partial volume effects, the spill-out effect seems to play a crucial role in the distribution of the image counts beyond the boundaries of the image pixels. However, more investigations are needed to accurately characterize limitations regarding the object size, background levels, and other factors.