Interobserver Agreement on the Interpretation of Programmed Death-ligand 1 (PD-L1) Combined Positive Score (CPS) Among Gynecologic Pathologists

Abstract

The anti-programmed cell death (PD-1) checkpoint inhibitor pembrolizumab is approved for the treatment of cervical carcinoma with a programmed cell death-ligand 1 (PD-L1) Combined Positive Score (CPS) of ≥1. We assessed interobserver agreement in cervical carcinoma PD-L1 CPS to identify whether it may affect patient selection for immunotherapeutic candidacy. Twenty-nine cervical carcinomas were stained for PD-L1 (Dako 22C3), and slides were interpreted by 5 subspecialty-trained gynecologic pathologists with experience reading PD-L1 immunohistochemistry. Expression was scored using CPS and read out as positive (≥1) or negative (<1); in positive cases, a final score was assigned (1 to 100). There was consensus agreement across all 5 pathologists for 90% (26/29) (Fleiss Kappa value for interobserver agreement: 0.799). The 3 cases with disagreement were composed of 2 squamous cell carcinomas and 1 small cell carcinoma. Of the 26 with unanimous agreement, 88% (23/26) were positive and 12% (3/26) were negative. All (16/16) pure squamous cell carcinomas with full consensus were interpreted as positive, whereas tumors with glandular components were commonly consensus negative (33%, 3/9); this difference was significant (P=0.037). Disagreements were attributable to low CPS versus negative reads (2 cases) and difficulty discerning glandular involvement from pushing invasion (1 case). In summary, experienced gynecologic pathologists showed substantial interobserver agreement in the interpretation of PD-L1 CPS at the Food and Drug Administration–approved treatment threshold, with the majority of tumors being classified as positive. Pure squamous histology was strongly associated with a consensus-positive read, whereas a subset of tumors with glandular differentiation was negative by all readers. Disagreements occurred in tumors with low versus negative CPS values and in the setting of limited invasion.