No Difference in Surgical Outcomes between Stand-Alone Devices and Anterior Plating for 1-2 level Anterior Cervical Discectomy and Fusion

Abstract

Study Design: Retrospective cohort. Objective: Compare rates of all-cause surgical and medical complications between zero-profile (stand-alone) implants versus any graft type with anterior plate in patients undergoing 1-2 level anterior cervical discectomy and fusion (ACDF) for treatment of degenerative cervical myeloradiculopathy. Summary of Background Data: Degenerative cervical myeloradiculopathy is increasingly prevalent in older adults. ACDF is a common surgical procedure for decompression of neural structures and stabilization and has been shown to have excellent outcomes. While ACDFs performed with a graft and plate has been the gold standard, more recently, zero-profile implants were developed to decrease implant related complications, such as severe postoperative dysphagia. However, there is a paucity of papers comparing the surgical and medical complications profile of zero-profile (stand-alone) implants to grafts with plating systems. Methods: Data was extracted from the PearlDiver Mariner Database using CPT codes to classify patients into 1-level, 2-levels, and total 1-2 level ACDFs. Patients undergoing surgery for non-degenerative pathologies such as tumors, trauma, or infection were excluded. Results: 1:1 exact matching created two equal groups of 7,284 patients that underwent 1-2 level ACDF with either grafting with a plate or zero-profile (standalone) implant. There were no statistically significant difference in all-cause surgical complications, pseudarthrosis rate, dysphagia or need for revision surgery between both cohorts (RR 0.99, 95% CI 0.80-1.21, P = 0.95). Additionally, all-cause medical complications were similar between both cohorts (RR 1.07, 95% CI 0.862-1.330, P = 0.573) or any specific surgical or medical complication included in this study. Conclusion: After 1:1 exact matching, the results of this study suggest that zero-profile (stand-alone) implants have similar outcomes compared to grafts with plating systems, with no observed differences in all-cause surgical or medical complications profile.