The Paediatric Vault Score (PVS)—A Novel Scoring Tool for Prioritisation of Surgical Management of Craniosynostosis Patients

Abstract

Craniosynostosis is the premature fusion of the skull sutures, resulting in abnormal skull shape and volume. Timely management is a priority in avoiding raised intracranial pressure which can result in blindness and neurodevelopmental delay. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, theater access was reduced. A risk stratification scoring system was thus devised to score patients attending surgery and aid in prioritization according to surgical need. The authors present the Paediatric Vault Score (PVS), which can also be customized to each unit’s individual protocols. Ten patients on the waiting list were randomly selected and their clinical information was summarized in uniform anonymized reports. Six craniofacial consultants were selected as assessors and given 1 week to independently rank the patients from 1 to 10. Each scorer’s ranking was verified against the PVS template and concordance was analyzed using the Kendall tau correlation coefficient (KT). Three cycles of the scoring process were carried out. Improvements were made to the scoring tool following cycle 1. Cycle 1 revealed 2 clinicians to be concordant with the PVS system and 4 to be discordant. Cycle 2 revealed all 6 clinicians to be concordant, with a mean KT score of 0.61. The final cycle revealed all 6 clinicians to be concordant, with a mean KT score of 0.70. Four scorers increased their concordance once the scoring sheet was introduced. Kendall’s correlation of concordance calculated the interrater reliability to be 0.81. The PVS is the first known vault scoring system to aid in risk stratification and waiting list prioritization.